Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

“Cracking the safe (excerpt)

A poor man must swing
For stealing a belt buckle
But if a rich man steals a whole state
He is acclaimed
As statesmen of the year . . .

Moral: the more you pile up ethical principles
And duties and obligations
To bring everyone in line
The more you gather loot
For a thief like Khang.
By ethical argument
And moral principle
The greatest crimes are eventually shown
To have been necessary, and, in fact,
A signal benefit
To mankind.”

― Thomas Merton, The Way of Chuang Tzu

I wish i had the energy and discipline to record Merton' entire rendering of Chuang Tsu, ix, 2. Here is my favorite part:

The invention
of weights and measures
makes robbery easier.
Signing contracts, setting seals,
makes robbery more sure.
Teaching love and duty
provides a fitting language
with which to prove that robbery
is really for the general good....

Kwang, if i recall correctly, was the legendary (?) leader of a most notorious gang of thieves.  He acquired his leadership position, not through strength or aggressiveness or ruthlessness or intelligence, but by following Taoist principles.  Whoever (probably not Chuan Chou) wrote this particular section), felt that since there were more bad men than good men in the world, wise teachings would do more harm than good since they are equally useful for everyone.
Perhaps this "wisdom" was "Confucian wisdom" rather than "Taoist wisdom," the author does not say.  Sages are blamed for the problems in the world, for the departure from simplicity.

This brings up my main problem with Taoist philosophy.  At the same time that it is democratic, even anarchic (though Merton would disagree), it is also elitist..  "One in ten is a follower of Tao."  "If that were not so it would not be the Tao."  "Taoist teaching should remain a secret treasure," "hidden in the ragged robes of the sage."  It reminds me of what a follower jokingly said of Dorothy Day.  "She believes in anarchy as long as she gets to be the chief anarch." (The Archanarch? :) )


( 2 comments — Leave a comment )
Apr. 29th, 2015 10:50 pm (UTC)
Apr. 30th, 2015 03:47 am (UTC)
You will enjoy Merton's Chuang Tzu/.
I have not enjoyed (nor learned from) Michell as much as i have hoped to learn.
Thomas Cleary has a good rendition of the the first seven (inner) chapters in his The Essential Tao
( 2 comments — Leave a comment )



Latest Month

August 2019


Page Summary

Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by Tiffany Chow